The Nature of the Beast

Initially, the Three Pines community debates the ethics of performing a play that was written by a convicted murderer. Analyze the novel’s overall portrayal of Fleming as a character to decide which side of the debate the author supports. Use specific examples from the text to support your argument.

When the death of Laurent Lepage is initially assumed to be accidental, what does this assumption imply about the collective mindset of the residents of Three Pines? Contrast this widespread belief with Gamache’s initial reaction and explain the reasons underlying his differing opinion.

Gamache is particularly terrified of John Fleming because he knows the full extent of the gruesome crimes that Fleming committed. Is it fair that Gamache has to carry this horrible knowledge? Why does Gamache keep this information a secret, and why does he eventually decide to disclose the gruesome details?